Raging Bull: Jake LaMotta’s Six Fight Saga With Sugar Ray Robinson

Jake LaMotta passed away on this day six years ago
07:00, 19 Sep 2023

When director Martin Scorsese released the biographical drama Raging Bull in 1980, it became the magnum opus of boxing films. But despite being one of the most revered pictures in cinema history, Jake LaMotta, Raging Bull’s protagonist, remains an enigmatic character to most.

Raging Bull, while not entirely accurate, gave viewers a fascinating insight into the self-destructive tendencies and rage that followed LaMotta throughout his career. Thanks to the film, viewers know more about the exploits of LaMotta out of the ring, rather than in it.

LaMotta isn’t one of the greatest middleweights of all-time but he was certainly one of the division’s toughest.

In the ring, LaMotta was best known for his six savage fights with Sugar Ray Robinson, a man whom many consider to be the best to ever lace up a pair of gloves. LaMotta won just one of the encounters between the two, but he always brought the best out of Robinson, pushing the all-time great to his absolute limits on more than one occasion, often leaving a pristine, white canvas looking like the location of a brutal massacre.

After retirement, LaMotta would say: “I fought Sugar Ray Robinson so many times, it's a wonder I don't have diabetes.” 

Turning professional in 1941, LaMotta quickly became a crowd favourite in the cigarette smoke-filled boxing halls littered throughout New York thanks to his high-pressure fighting style. A little over a year after his debut, Jake had put together an impressive record of 25-4-2 and was scheduled to fight Robinson for the first time. 


Making his debut at middleweight, Ray Robinson was dropped early on in the first round at Madison Square Gardens before going on to win a comfortable unanimous decision.

The rematch came just four months later, this time in Detroit, and Ray Robinson was given a huge wake up call in the eighth round when LaMotta sprung a catastrophic right to Robinson’s head and a devastating left to his body, sending him flying through the ropes. Robinson was saved by the bell at the count of nine, but LaMotta was relentless and battered the man from Georgia for the rest of the fight, cruising to a unanimous decision, handing Sugar the first loss of his career in the process. 

Robinson had won all 30 of his fights before that night in the Motor City and would stay unbeaten for another 91 after it, such was the magnitude of LaMotta’s win. His moment of glory wouldn’t last long, though - three weeks to be exact. On February 26, 1943, the two rivals met for the third time in just over four months and the second time in just 21 days - an astonishing timeframe when compared to the current era of boxing.

In another razor-thin encounter, Robinson was dropped by a dazzling left but it wouldn’t be enough as Robinson outworked LaMotta for the remainder of the bout, taking another close unanimous decision. LaMotta fumed at the decision and claimed that it was only given to Robinson because he was going to be inducted into the Army the next day. 

After three brutal wars in quick succession, it would take nearly two years for the pair to meet again. On a chilly February night in New York in 1945, Robinson came away with yet another unanimous decision in perhaps the least thrilling of their six-fight saga.

They would fight once more in 1945, in September at Chicago’s Comiskey Park, and the result is still a hot topic among fight fans to this day. This time the two combatants were separated by a split decision, which went in Robinson’s favour, leaving the 14,755 people in attendance to angrily boo the result. LaMotta would have to wait six more years for the final showdown with his nemesis.

PA 32920666jpg

The final fight with Ray Robinson happened in 1951 on Valentine’s Day in Chicago and would come to be known as the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre, a play on the infamous gangland hit ordered by Chicago mobster Al Capone on the same day in 1929.

Portrayed beautifully by Robert DeNiro in Raging Bull, the sixth fight between these two has gone down in boxing lore. Towards the end of the fight, LaMotta took a brutal and bloody beating at the hands of Sugar Ray, unable to throw anything back. He just stood there, bombarded by lightning quick jabs and uppercuts, simply refusing to go down.

The fight came to an end in the 13th round with LaMotta slumped on the ropes, clearly defeated but defiant that the great Sugar Ray Robinson had never dropped him despite them sharing 65 rounds in the ring with one another.

His violent temperament, mob connections and turbulent life outside of the ring meant LaMotta’s story was made for the silver screen but his wars with Sugar Ray are what define his career as a boxer and his name will live on in the sport’s history forever because of it. He might not be as lauded as Ray Robinson is now, but LaMotta gave arguably the best boxer ever, the six hardest fights of a 199 fight career.

To quote LaMotta himself: "The three toughest fighters I ever fought were Sugar Ray Robinson, Sugar Ray Robinson and Sugar Ray Robinson.”

Suggested Searches:
The Sportsman
Manchester United
Manchester City
Premier League
Sportsman HQ
72-76 Cross St
Manchester M2 4JG
We will not ask you to provide any personal information when using The Sportsman website. You may see advertisement banners on the site, and if you choose to visit those websites, you will accept the terms and conditions and privacy policy applicable to those websites. The link below directs you to our Group Privacy Policy, and our Data Protection Officer can be contacted by email at: [email protected]

All original material is Copyright © 2019 by The Sportsman Communications Ltd.
Other material is copyright their respective owners.