Two Years Ago Today: Josh Taylor Beats Jack Catterall By Controversial Decision

The Tartan Tornado controversially retained his WBA, WBC, IBF and WBO straps with a split decision win
09:31, 26 Feb 2024

Two years ago today, Josh Taylor retained the undisputed super lightweight championship of the world with a controversial split decision win over Jack Catterall. With the rematch finally set for this coming April, The Sportsman presents our original fight report from their first meeting. Read on for our immediate reaction to one of the most contentious decisions to ever take place in a British ring.

In one of the worst boxing decisions in recent memory, Josh Taylor retained his status as undisputed super-lightweight champion with a controversial split-decision win over Jack Catterall at the OVO Hydro in Glasgow.

‘The Tartan Tornado’ had made pre-fight boasts that he would outclass Catterall when they met in the ring, but instead found himself outmatched by his English rival and was incredibly lucky to exit his homecoming fight with his WBA, WBC, IBF and WBO straps still intact. 

Mandatory challenger ‘El Gato’, a 17-2 betting underdog, started brightly against the Prestonpans southpaw and the champion was outboxed for most of the early rounds, with the Chorley native building up what looked to be a formidable lead on the scorecards. 


A bad night at the office for Taylor turned into a disaster in the eighth, when the local hero was floored. Although Catterall was deducted a point for holding in the ninth, offering the home fighter some respite, Taylor then found himself on the end of a point deduction a few rounds later for clocking Catterall after the bell. 

A few rounds were too close to call, but all signs pointed to Taylor needing a knockout to count his Scotland ring return a success and when the final bell rang, few could begrudge Catterall wheeling away in celebration, having clearly outmaneuvered and outskilled his opponent across the 12 rounds.

Catterall put in an astonishing shift north of the border tonight and simply couldn’t have done any more to win the fight on the scorecards. So the rulings of 113-112 in favour of Catterall, and 114-111 and 113-112 in favour of Taylor, will quite rightly leave a sour taste in the mouths of boxing fans everywhere. 

Despite the controversial win, Taylor is adamant he deserved the nod and doesn’t know if he’ll offer Catterall a rematch. 

"I 100 per cent [believed I had done enough to win],” he told Sky Sports.

“It wasn't my best performance and he caught me with some good shots. I put a lot of pressure on myself and it showed in the first half of the fight but when I found my rhythm I started catching him. I know I won the fight."

"It is getting harder to make the weight and that will most likely be my last fight at 140.  I don't think there is any need for a rematch. I won in the second half of the fight. I took over and bossed him."

Catterall’s trainer Jamie Moore spoke passionately about the controversial defeat in the aftermath, saying: "You are talking about a kid who has worked hard all his life, who beats a champion in his own backyard and is robbed. 

“Think about the message that sends. It is disgusting. I don't even know what to say. Jack is heartbroken."

Two-time Olympic gold medallist Robeisy Ramirez, 9-1 (5), showed his class with an electric stoppage win over Eric Donovan, 14-2 (8). The Cuban featherweight, who beat Shakur Stevenson in the 56kgs final at Rio 2016, dropped the five-time Irish national champion in the opening stanza before ending proceedings in the third with a huge left hook. Ramirez lost his pro debut to Adan Gonzalez which left some question marks over his potential in the paid ranks, but a career-best win tonight showed that the sky’s the limit for the slick southpaw.


In the first Scottish Area heavyweight title scrap since 1951 and the most bizarre fight of the card, former Glasgow Warriors star Nick Campbell (5-0) stopped a woefully outmatched Jay McFarlane in seven rounds. Campbell, a former teammate of darts ace Gerwyn Price, was forced to huff and puff against his compatriot to get the knockout and, despite dominating, didn’t exactly set the world alight with his own performance. 

Highly-rated welterweight Paddy Donovan extended his fight record to 8-0 (6) after halting Miroslav Serban in six rounds. The Andy Lee-trained ‘Real Deal’ never really needed to get out of first gear, easily outclassing the Czech Republic native in another impressive display from the 23-year-old

In her second professional outing, Boxxer super-bantamweight prospect Ebonie Jones (1-0-1) was held to a surprising 57-57 draw by Effy Kathopouli. The Portsmouth fighter looked to have just about nicked the fight, displaying some nifty footwork and decent punch variety that caused her Greek opponent some difficulty in the earlier rounds. However, the intense affair was far from one-way traffic, with a defiant Kathopouli taking a footing from the third round. 

The evening’s TV coverage opened with an all-Scottish super middleweight affair between Jordan Grant and John Docherty. ‘The Doc’ ended the fight swiftly, stopping Grant in the second round after following up a superb body shot with a shot to the forehead. The 2018 Commonwealth Games bronze medallist moves to 12-1 (11). 

Full Card Results

  • Josh Taylor bt Jack Catterall PTS

  • Robeisy Ramirez bt Eric Donovan via TKO3

  • Nick Campbell bt Jay McFarlane via TKO7 

  • Ebonie Jones draws with Effy Kathopouli

  • Paddy Donovan bt Miroslav Serban via TKO6

  • John Docherty bt Jordan Grant via KO2

  • Bilal Fawaz bt Malam Varela via TKO3

  • Scott Forrest bt Erik Nazaryan RTD2

  • Kurt Walker bt Jaroslav Hriadel TKO1

  • Kieran Molloy bt Damian Esquisabel TKO2

  • Mark McKeown bt Engale Gomes PTS

Suggested Searches:
The Sportsman
Manchester United
Manchester City
Premier League
Sportsman HQ
72-76 Cross St
Manchester M2 4JG
We will not ask you to provide any personal information when using The Sportsman website. You may see advertisement banners on the site, and if you choose to visit those websites, you will accept the terms and conditions and privacy policy applicable to those websites. The link below directs you to our Group Privacy Policy, and our Data Protection Officer can be contacted by email at: [email protected]

All original material is Copyright © 2019 by The Sportsman Communications Ltd.
Other material is copyright their respective owners.