Former WBC heavyweight champion ‘The Nigerian Nightmare’ Samuel Peter turns 41 today. Despite holding a portion of the heavyweight crown, the sixth-round knockout of Oleg Maskaevwhich saw him claim the belt is not what Peter is best known for. Rather, the Uyo, Nigeria knockout artist is most famous for a fight he didn’t win. On 24 September 2005, Peter would knock down former and future world heavyweight champion Wladimir Klitschko three times on the way to losing a unanimous decision. This thrilling heavyweight humdinger would mark the last time Klitschko was knocked down in a fight for over 11 years, before Anthony Joshua sent him to the canvas in April 2017.
It is hard to put into words just how much Samuel Peter meant to boxing aficionados in the heavyweight nuclear winter of 2005. There was a vacuum at the top of boxing’s decaying banner division, with superstars declining or departing, and the heavyweight championship scattered to the wind. ‘Iron’ Mike Tyson had slumped into retirement after being stopped by Kevin McBridge in June. Lennox Lewis had retired as WBC and lineal champion a year before, while Evander Holyfield had been comprehensively beaten in his last three fights. The IBF strap was around the waist of the slick but light-hitting Chris ‘Rapid Fire Byrd’, the WBA belt was in possession of John Ruiz, the WBO bauble belonged to Lamon Brewster and the WBC championship would be vacated in two months’ time by the injured Vitali Klitschko. Shorn of stars, and with a fractured championship, heavyweight boxing was at its nadir.
Samuel Peter appeared to be the perfect tonic. An unblemished 24-0 record with 21 knockouts, had boxing hardcores salivating. His wins over fringe contenders Charles Shufford, Taurus Sykes and Jeremy Williams, coupled with his highlight reel of knockouts, had many touting him as the latest ‘Next Mike Tyson’. Peter faced a huge step-up in class however, when he signed to fight former WBO titleist Wladimir Klitschko.
This was not quite the dominant ‘Dr Steelhammer’ we remember so vividly today. While he had held the WBO championship at this point, he had lost it via a chilling second-round TKO defeat to South African Corrie Sanders. Klitschko had also been stopped by Lamon Brewster while trying to regain the same belt, as well as suffering an early-career TKO loss to unheralded Ross Purrity. In 2005, Wladimir was a boxer in transition. He had racked up two wins since the chastening Brewster defeat, but DaVarryl Williamson had sent him to the canvas in the first of those. Klitschko entered the Peter fight as the underdog due to his opponent’s incredible power, and his own suspect chin.
The pair finally met in Atlantic City, New Jersey, in a fight that would define both their careers. Klitschko started fast, perhaps sensing that letting the concussive puncher establish his rhythm could be fatal. Working excellently behind a jab that would go on to dominate an entire division, Wladimir landed several warning shots with his right hand early on. Peter was undeterred, barreling forward looking for one big punch to turn the tide. In the fifth round he found it, twice. A pair of messy, wild hooks connected and on both occasions the Ukrainian fell to the canvas. An untidy fight from the get-go, with Klitschko initiating a lot of clinches, both punches seemed to catch Wladimir towards the back of his head. The referee awarded both as knockdowns though, and Klitschko’s dream redemption began to look like a ‘Nigerian Nightmare’.
The 6-foot-7 brother of Vitali held on for dear life, and tried to slow the pace in the following rounds, but found himself rocked in the eighth with a solid right hand. The tone and tenor of the fight were now set. Peter would storm ceaselessly forward attempting to uncork a knockout punch, while Klitschko peppered him with hard jabs and straight rights in a fruitless effort to stop him. Peter walked through fire time and again, shrugging at the sort of shots that would undo Klitschko’s next 19 opponents. The Ukrainian artillery was not enough to prevent another crisis in the 10th, as a crunching right hook sent Wladimir staggering across the squared circle. Peter followed it up with a straight right hand to send him down, and at this point the fight looked to be a formality.
But, unlike against Brewster, or Sanders, or Purrity, this time Klitschko refused to stay down. He rose once again and the fight slotted back into its natural rhythm. Peter drove in, feeling like one more shot would do it. The shot never came, and he himself was rattled by a sharp Klitschko left hook in the final round. The fight went to the scorecards, and despite being knocked down three times, Klitschko took the unanimous decision.
This heavyweight classic, delivered just when the flagging division needed it most, would do wonders for the careers of both men. Peter shrugged off defeat the same way he shrugged off Klitschko’s punches, and racked up five wins in a row, including two against the legendary James ‘Lights Out’ Toney. He would beat Oleg Maskaev for the WBC championship in 2008, before the curse of the Klitschkos struck him again. He relinquished his title to Wladimir’s older brother, Vitali, via TKO after eight completed rounds.
For Wladimir, this fight was the first day of the rest of his career. He would not lose again for a decade, winning the IBF championship by stopping Chris Byrd in his next outing, and eventually unifying it with the WBO, WBA and Ring Magazine iterations of the title. He would also meet Samuel Peter again along the way, but their rematch was not a patch on the original. Klitschko won a one-sided bout by knockout in the 10th round, effectively ending Peter’s run as a world class heavyweight and bringing their dispute full circle.
Samuel Peter never replaced Mike Tyson as a mainstream icon, but his career lives long in the memory. He has not boxed since 2019, but this phenomenal war has etched his name into boxing folklore, and coupled with his WBC title win, makes for a credible legacy for the ‘Nigerian Nightmare’.